6. Honda Civic
Some may say the prior-generation version of Honda’s popular compact sedan is superior to the current iteration. Most versions come powered by a peppy and efficient four-cylinder engine; a quicker and sportier Si rendition is also available, but it’s likely to cost more both up front and down the road in terms of higher insurance rates. Teens have even voted that they like this body style compared to other models of cars made during the same years. Estimated annual insurance premium: $3,738.