5. Toyota Corolla
This is certainly a safe and sane choice among used cars for drivers of all ages. The Corolla performs well, is reasonably comfortable, has proven to be reliable and gets great fuel mileage. For better or worse, it’s conservatively styled inside and out and does little to encourage reckless behavior behind the wheel. It’ll be sure to keep a teen humble and in the right mindset while on the roads. Estimated annual insurance premium: $3,656.